Threepenny Opera as performed by a college theater I knew would be a risk. At worst, the singers would be very bad, the accents annoyingly awful, making such a potently odd musical downright painful. On these points, they were actually pretty good. They were all miked, which helped.
Most of the leads were fairly strong, Macheath, Polly, Peachum (channeling Sean Bean) and Tiger Brown. The accents were either pretty good, or kept mild - no Dick Van Dykes. Filch was pure scene stealer, enjoyably so.
But as the lesser singers took over the second act, I began to focus on the irritations. The set was five grey bleachers, that moved side to side across the stage, changing the entrance spaces. Clever, sure, but they also shifted as people walked from one to the other alarmingly. The staging around this set of steep steps was busy and random, and very distracting, as actors perched awkwardly. The costumes were also way too busy, a sort of punk/goth sensibility, but without distinguishing the different groups, everything layered and flappy with extra chains and zippers and the same colors. Which, if used just for the beggars, or just MacHeath's gang, would have been fine. Much the same could be said for the make-up, which if used with restraint, was very Avant-Garde, Cabaret, Blade Runner. There was no such restraint, only distraction.
They also used smoke. Got in my nose and sinuses. And, again, to no real purpose. Other, harder to describe, over reliance on electronic gimmicks, made for a bit of a mess.
Still, worth going. Some nice performances amid the muddle. The rain held off, and the night stayed mild as we waited for the train. And we plan to get the movie later today. I've watched it several times, rough little gem.
3 comments:
It sounds entertaining in many ways. I enjoyed Traviata in Kazakhstan, sung in 'Italian' with Russian subtitles on the side.
I haven't seen a college play in many years, perhaps not even since I was in college myself.
RR,
Your experience sounds much more interesting.
Phil,
We go now and again, sometimes they've been quite well done here.
Post a Comment