Friday, August 05, 2011

Should

Long ago, I saw a student production of a pretty forgettable play. But a phrase out of it has been stuck in my head ever since, and I find myself still saying it. "Should'a, could'a, would'a, if my aunt was a man she'd be my uncle."

Should never helps. Just because one has plans doesn't mean life will cooperate. Putting in effort does not guarantee results. Hope is more often dashed than fulfilled. Dreams fall apart on contact with waking life. Belief has fueled a lot of misguided missions. We can always choose to love, and find happiness, and live well. But we can never demand love of others, expect to be given what we think we need to make us happy, nor force health and wealth out of the world for ourselves. Life does not guarantee our next breath, why do we so often think we are owed a One True Love, a Great Career, Happiness! and Health? Or any of a number of benefits?

Lucky to be alive.

I once read an interpretation of the Pandora story, where the final evil was leaving humanity with hope. That desire to hold on and keep on trying, beyond reason, and to call it a virtue. Hope, not as the opposite of hopeless, but as the kind of idealism that keeps us from actually solving a problem, instead merely wishing it will get better. Wishes are chocolate kettles.* If wishes worked, a lot of awful people would be dead, I should know.


Worn out and squished out, will be better in a day or so.


*That waxy chocolate that tastes of chalk.

7 comments:

gz said...

(o)




the Word is "typed".!

Relatively Retiring said...

I love that memorable phrase from the play.
Shoulds, woulds and coulds are marginally better than 'oughts'.
There's a good counselling-type phrase about 'hardening of the oughteries'.
Get better soon.

Joan said...

No sense wasting good chocolate on a kettle. Hershey's it is then!

Feel better soon-- this too shall pass!

Zhoen said...

RR,
Oh, puns, where would we be without 'em.

Joan,
I was thinking Brachs. Which makes Hershey taste rather good.

Pacian said...

I'm an optimist, it's my worst vice. I know nothing has to work out well, or even take the edge off the bad things, but I don't want to believe it.

A person with nothing to be sad about is still a sad person if they have nothing to be happy about.

mbick said...

The phrase from the play is definitely a keeper.
I laughed at the "I should know" regarding the wishing causing a death.

Phil Plasma said...

(o)