Wednesday, March 21, 2007

Girl

This is not articulate, consider it thinking out loud.


I had a chat with a rep this week, on the subject of his preschool daughters, and schoolyard fights, and how girls fight dirty. It started as a discussion of tattoos, and I talked about getting mine when I was 35, which progressed to a debate on piercings, and then to earrings, and how I waited until age 16 to pierce my ears. I'd seen girls tug on earrings in the playground, and my own Granny had a ripped earlobe from just such a grade school girl fight, in 1898.

Girls are generally not taught to fight, or if they are it is in the context of "If a big bad man attacks you!" in which case, the only chance a small girl has is to fight dirty, bite, scratch, run, scream blue hell.

My own brother, attacked by assailants with a chain, walking home from a high school dance, spent a week in a hospital with a concussion, and became a bit obsessed with self defense. Being 11 years younger meant I soaked up his anxiety, his pupil in his version of martial arts. His directions for me were always of the, go for the 'eyes, testicles, shins' variety. Sensible, pragmatic, real life lessons. Meant I was even more terrified of getting in a fight with a girl, knowing they would fight me tooth and claw. When girls fight, there are no rules, other than to win by any means. Good survival tactic, but a debased sense of fairness bleeds into other aspects of life. As anyone who works with a large group of women, or watches COPS! Bad Girls Specials! knows.


Boys, at least at one time, were taught rules of fair play. Not that there were not plenty of bullies and that Us v Them rule for applying the rules. At least there were rules of some kind. Girls are taught not to fight, to expect kind treatment, and if that is violated, then unsheathe claws and defend. Or not. Today, girls in gangs are gaining notoriety for fighting harder and dirtier, using weapons readily, adding a special horror to the already pervasive and unrestricted male violence in poor and drug soaked urban issues. Any move is good, any lie that works.

Fighting is too important and wild an aspect of human interaction, to be left to chance. Ignoring female violence, or treating it as something aberrant or special, simply invites in further chaos. Martial arts, with the sense of individual accomplishment, controlled power applied fairly, could ease the erratically escalating brutality. Imbue in every child a moral compass of justice and fair play, in the deeply emotional atmosphere of ritualized violence. Do less, deflect, if possible, but win if attacked.

Animals apply this principle of threat and display, to avoid the damage of a maiming or mortal clash. Live to mate another day. Boys and girls need to internalize all these ideas, fairness, survival, risk assessment. A middle ground between false safety and drive by shootings.

What they have is ready access to images of violence, steeped in fear, given no handrails to steady them. All mixed up in sex and gender roles, and squeamish public education stuck in Evagelical Victorian illusions, parents absent or overwhelmed or abusive themselves, jangling against graphic video games and action movies, both boys and girls are expected to just know how to fight fair and be generous lovers, when they get their driver's license.

In our human passions, fighting and loving, we need most to be fair. Our cultures fail us when they don't bother to teach us how. Worse when we are expected to be weak, only able to survive by playing dirty. It's getting worse very fast.

6 comments:

Fire Bird said...

This IS articulate, and gives me a lot of food for thought. I'm too tired to be articulate now, but thankyou for it.

mark drago said...

agree w/tg--though would say no true diff bet. girls/boys. idea of "no rules" just preconception of "femininity". and "culture"--what is it?

mark drago said...

(pls pardon my tediousness, too)

Zhoen said...

TG, Welcome.

Mark, yes. Just that boys and girls are expected to fight differently. Or something. Femininity, masculinity, all twisting the data. I guess I wanted girls to be allowed the Idea of fighting, which is largely denied.

No pardon, I'm being tedious too. Just, an idea for discussion, no fixed opinion.

Nancy Ruth said...

The growing violence among girls is troubling. We used to limit our violence to catty words. How to teach a girl to fight fair? My brother said that one problem with women in his church as committee chairs was that they had never been on a sports team so didn't know how to cooperate -- had to do the job all by themselves. Could that be the case with learning to fight fair? I remember the two fights I had as a child with absolute clarity.

Lucy said...

Yes, it is articulate.
We want to contain the chaos somehow, don't we. You may well be right as to the way to go, but society fragments so, and we cannot find a common will about this or much else either.
I sometimes think that the idea of women as somehow less violent is a comparitively recent blip in our history, on the other hand testosterone is a fact...
Tom (husband) grew up with the settling of fights by Queensbury rules at school. It wasn't fair and it didn't stop bullying but it did ritualise and contain things.
Lots to think about here. Thanks Z.