Thursday, August 20, 2015

Face



Introversion.

I've never been a great conversationalist. I tend not to ask many questions, not from lack of interest, but fearing "pestering" and avoiding intrusiveness. After going to so many new places, and having to answer so many of the same questions, I tend not to ask others the same, being tired of them myself.

Where are you from? Where were you born? Married? Children?

Born in Detroit, but haven't been there in decades, don't want to go back, not sure it says anything much about me today. Married, yes, but, well. Twice, but that's not casual conversation, given that the ex was abusive. Never wanted children, but I don't want to get into that on a superficial basis.

So, I have stock answers. Like how I wound up in Utah, "ex husband, long story." I begin to understand why all my drill sergeants, when asked where they came from said "my mamma."

Growing up, among children there, "what are you?" meant what cultures you came from, Mexican, Irish, Black, Italian, Polish, whatever. As kids, it probably said a lot about us. In my 50s, not much at all.

I understand it's an accepted way to open discussion, but I'm tired of it. And I don't ask questions, because I tend to diagnose on not much data. I don't want to know more than people are intending to tell me, and since I do anyway, I try to mitigate. Try not to ask too much, not to pry. I'll hear anything, nothing bothers me, but I wonder if others realize how much they are telling me?

So, I relate a story, and hope they return one. It's a real struggle to actually ask a question, as I so want to avoid triteness, repetition, or intrusion with reflexive analysis. I suspect this shows in my comments.

Sorry.


11 comments:

Relatively Retiring said...

Your comments show thoughfulness, kindness and a great sense of humour.

Phil Plasma said...

Occasionally I'll meet someone who not that long ago had their first or second child. A common question to such people is to ask 'are you planning on having another?'. I, instead, ask, "do people often ask you about having another?"

Generally I'm not one for small talk, but under certain situations I'm able to ask fairly uncommon questions that doesn't put a person through the typical 'place born and raised, job, married, etc'.

I don't get the same sense of intrusion that you get, I put trust into people that they will tell me if I ever make them uncomfortable or if they ever do not want to answer a question, but usually I am fairly judicious about asking questions in the first place.

The Crow said...

I echo what RR said, and add a truthfulness found rarely in others. I appreciate you just as you are, couldn't want you to be anything else - in fact, I'm grateful to have made your acquaintance here.

valonia said...

I also agree with Relatively Retiring, and I apologise for the myriad of questions I always ask.

the polish chick said...

no sorry needed. as rr said, your comments might be minimal, but always thoughtful. i'm the other end of the spectrum - gregarious, oversharing, talkative. frankly, since i'm 50/50 extro/intro, i often tire of myself and wish i would just shut up, a skill that (i think) i'm getting better at as the years go by.

Fresca said...

I recently mentioned on my blog that people who don't ask questions aren't a good match for me. (I specified men, because in my experience more of them tend to be in that category, but of course women do it too.)

I was thinking about this because I was pondering looking for a lover/partner. I rub along just fine with all sorts of communicators among coworkers, casual acquaintances, etc.
And I very much like the "swap stories" style of communication that blogs facilitate so well.

But I should have been more specific about non-question-askers:
There are other ways to signal interest besides asking questions.
What I really meant was people who never signal *in some way* an interest in listening to the other person, such as pausing in their own speech, making open eye contact, having an open body pose... not to mention turning off their phone!

I understand some people don't want or like to (or cannot) do this, and I don't mean to imply that's a bad thing---it's just that I would not be a good match for them, with my highly chatty style ("too intense" used to be a common complaint--less now at midlife).

gz said...

(O)

Fresca said...

P.S. In my case, "What are you?" helps explain my conversational style.

Father: From an Italian family, where everyone talked at once, for hours (wonderful, except when it wasn't: there was always someone who wasn't talking to someone else-- silence was used as a weapon, a punishment, a shunning)

Mother: From US South porch-sitters: hours and hours of talk (stories, gossip, etc.)

Zhoen said...

(mumble)

Oh, um, well. Glad I don't come off so bad written.

valonia said...

Not sure why my comment posted three times, but have deleted two of them.

Zhoen said...

valonia,

Not just you, I've seen this happen a lot lately, including here. Meant to tidy up this morning, but I forgot. Can't do that sort of cleaning at work, and I spent way too many hours there the last three days.