Friday, August 29, 2014

Nightmare

Not the worst case, nor the worst patient, not really, although I struggle to clearly remember any as bad. Chipper and self involved, manipulative and saccharine, a young, trained singer, the story is she is an opera singer, who insisted on getting a block and sedation to avoid an intubation. Not in itself an unreasonable preference, but we have laryngeal masks, that could have been managed. And taking out hardware is not a reliable surgery, it either goes very well and quickly, or very badly and takes a long time.

We were also waiting for her, late, and with insurance issues, and the pre-op crew were trying to get her ready quickly - which they do very well. They asked her to open the door when she was changed. Seemed to be taking a while, they gave her extra time before knocking, only to find her sitting there reading scripture.*

When I greet her by name, and ask her what she goes by, she tells me her rather dramatic and unusual middle name (think - Winterella.†) In a bright, overfriendly voice. Ugh, I think. She chatters on the whole time.

The ROH ¬ does not, as expected, go well. Non-union, no bone in the middle -just connective matrix, so taking out the plate would leave her with an unstable bone. Surgeon goes to her head to tell her this, and that he'll have to put on a new plate. She begins sobbing, uncontrolled in any way, loud. I'm getting the necessary implants and tools, drill, c-arm, and the resident anesthesiologist tells me the patient wants a song played. I do know keeping her calm is important, but it's down the list a bit at this moment.

Thankfully, the program I have running for music does allow a song/album choice, and after a minute or two, I find the song. A hymn ‡, on an album from BYU. Anesthesia resident asks me to turn it up, amid other things I'm doing so they can fix the bone, I turn it up. And then I get asked to start it over. I ignore this, as I am doing more critical tasks.

Patient starts singing along. Loudly. Off key. To the sappiest sort of hymn you hopefully cannot imagine. I'm in hell. At least the whining, sobbing stop while she's singing. Surgeon has broken scrub to talk with her family to get consent, since she's been difficult to convince. She does agree, but under sedation, this is not considered consent. Then she cries for the surgeon. The resident surgeon rolls his eyes at me, and puts on his deepest most reassuring voice, and she latches on to him for male comfort. I continue to keep everything afloat as different items are needed, surgeon returns, she sings loudly and sobs intermittently, nearly squirms off the table, so I get an extra safety strap on her.

This goes on for hours. She is tough, despite all the whining. Give her that.

Her singing is of the pretty, pop star variety. Trained, strong, but warbles all over melody without every actually settling on one.

The sort of voice one says "She's so clear. I can understand all the words!" As though that were some kind of artistic virtue. As my 75 year old patient told me this week about the sort of music she likes.


If I want to hear the words, I'll listen to speech. I'll read the damn lyric sheet, if I care that much.

Singing isn't about clear verbal communication, most lyrics are silly, and I can't stand clear, merely, pretty voices. I prefer the rugged beauty of souls who have suffered and endured. Aretha Franklin has a beautiful voice. Bob Dylan has a beautiful voice. Nina Simone had a beautiful voice. Nothing to do with pretty, or understanding the words. Fuck understanding the words. Music is beyond words, if you think you understand by articulation, the soul is lost. I detest musical pablum. Who understands the words in Opera?

She again delayed us by keeping the surgeon talking to her as we got the next case ready. As far as we could do, needed surgeon, had to drag him away from talking with her, telling her the same information over and over. And over.

When I have needed treatment, I make sure to say, 'do what you usually do. You know best what works well.' And I'm so aware of my own role as my own advocate, and not at all obedient. But I don't want to unnecessarily upset routine, since that sets me up for random distraction problems. Like you don't tell your waiter how to put down the plates.

I sometimes have to sit on my hands not to help in restaurants, but I know it's important not to interfere. Not to make too many special requests. Not because I'm wrong, but because it may not work. Let the people who are good at their jobs get on with it, once the decision is made.

Yes, I did work a very long, difficult day. Not quite 12 hours.



*Book Of Mormon related.
¬Removal of Hardware. Usually for pain, pushing through the skin. Most hardware will stay in permanently. At least, that's the intention.
‡LDS liturgical music is mild, bland, and child-friendly. Dull.
†The real name is actually more phony sounding, reality always beats fiction for unbelievability.

13 comments:

Relatively Retiring said...

This would make the most wonderful play for radio!

gz said...

What a day!

Zhoen said...

RR,
If so, I wouldn't listen to it.

The anesthesia attending got some of it recorded on her phone.

gz,
But I had beer at the end of it, so that's alright.

Phil Plasma said...

Some people are so full of themselves they really haven't any room for anything/anyone else.

Zhoen said...

Phil,
I think you have put your finger on exactly what bothered me about her. If she'd been 14, that's what I would have expected, and not minded.

FARMGAL said...

I never understand the words in opera, but it is one of my most cherished and loved things. Who needs words when people sing emotion??? That's one heck of a day, glad you survived!

Zhoen said...

FG,
At least a good story to tell. My only risk of not surviving was self-mercy-killing.

Singing is, I agree, about emotion. Not diction.

flask said...

i am sorry about your nightmare patient. what i have to say now in no way detracts from the horrible saccharine nature of the situation.

there's kind of a standard music school education. different music schools have different programs, btu everybody's getting a certain number of semesters of certain kinds of subjects.

singers will typically have to take TWO SEMESTERS of diction. these are courses that are about nothing besides how to pronounce the words in english, italian, french, german, latin, and sometimes spanish and russian.

while we sometimes sing with relaxed diction, being able to pronounce words clearly and correctly is in fact a basic professional skill.

Zhoen said...

flask,
Oh, I'm not saying it's not a skill. But it's not what music is about. Grammar does not make a great novel, draftsmanship does not guarantee a great painting that moves people throughout the centuries, perfect scansion doesn't mean a meaningful poem.

The best artists know the rules, then break them. Art is enhanced by this sort of skill, but isn't defined by it.

And who knows how many wild and powerful talents have been whittled down by excessive technique?

flask said...

art is not some weird arcane thing without proper skill and technique.

sure, grammar is not great poetry in much the same way as anatomy is not great surgery.

you kind of need it, though.

wild talent is only enhanced by good technique.

Zhoen said...

flask,
But just technique is not art. This is my point. An articulate singer does not necessarily have any soul.

I utterly disagree with you. Art is arcane. Built on a foundation of technique, but without the wild talent, it's dead. An over-trained singer without talent is tedious. An untrained singer with talent is still fascinating.

the polish chick said...

this is why i despise having "subtitles" with my opera, something they've started doing of late: not only does it detract from the pleasure of listening, but shows you how utterly inane the translated lyrics often are.

thank god i no longer have to deal with patients - i often had very little patience (har har) with people whose fear of the dentist was something they cherished and made into some precious commodity rather than a childish hold-over they should have attempted to get over already. mainly women, for some reason, though a few men as well.

made me want to slap them up the side of the head and tell them some daily story of real human struggle from rwanda or another such place where people survive against overwhelming odds.

Zhoen said...

pc,
Indeed, some people love their sense of being the star of their own DRAMA! And there we are just trying to do our jobs properly.

Nothing more foolish than opera lyrics, except perhaps pop lyrics.