Shiny

I once watched everything Disney with the rapt admiration of a child for the shiniest object in view. I loved the smoothness of the animation, the emotions of little Dumbo cradled by his imprisoned mother, the creation of a more colorful world. But as I got older, I began to sense the deep misogyny, and the obvious racism, as well as the aggressive marketing. Stories of Disneyland and -world taking visitors, turning them over and shaking until all their money fell out were common long before EuroDisney's issues with poor treatment of their employees. (Not to mention abuse of artists right from the beginning of the Disney Studios.) Accidents hushed up, local takeover of law enforcement, surface gloss to cover cracking infrastructure.

These days, I resent the Disney takeover of classic children's books, turning them into sly and suggestive, and overblown, PG rated films. Selling crack to kids. Pushing the Princess ideal to little girls, when real princesses were political pawns, whored out to whatever noble could pay in influence. That it is now seen as a fairy tale in pink sickens me. That girls see this as what they should be, instead of pursuing intellectual, or even spiritual study, undermines our humanity.

Disney is a huge, multinational corporation out to get our money, and every child in the world's money. That some folks react to any criticism of it as though I were kicking a puppy, is just ridiculous. It's not harmless. We live by our stories, and when we give over our stories to the most mercenary, and effectively larcenous, company, is poisonous.

At least one reader, long ago, took umbrage at my calling the megacorp of Disney evil. She left in a huff. Didn't bother me.

I once much preferred the Disney Winnie the Pooh, baffled by the appeal of the E. H. Shepard drawings. I got a little older, and knew better. I came to appreciate not having all the lines colored in to perfection, allowing the space for my own interpretation and participation.

Labels:

14 comments:

Blogger Pacian said...

And yet it's difficult to appreciate American animation while avoiding them - especially now they own Pixar.

16:07  
Blogger Zhoen said...

Pixar has, or at least had, some independence from them. Still, yes, it's a problem.

Those bastards.

16:46  
Blogger Lucy said...

I've been particualarly horrified of late how they've so brazenly and cynically appropriated the Narnia stories in collusion with the religious right, and how Douglas Gresham has so shamefully gone along with it.

However questionable the stories were from some points of view, they didn't deserve that.

01:50  
Blogger Liz said...

Princess-dom is a terrible aspiration to peddle to little girls - I'm with you on this one.

04:44  
Blogger Fire Bird said...

Oops, signed in to wromg google account - that was in fact me...

04:45  
Blogger Gina E. said...

Oooh dear, you do hate Disney with a passion!! I don't feel quite so strongly, but I do see your point of view here. More than 30 years ago, I visited the USA three times, and not once did I visit Disneyland anywhere. Not just because of the cost, but there was nothing at all to attract me. I had a much better time at nature's own wonderlands at Yellowstone Park, the Grand Canyon, etc. People back here said I was mad not to go to Disney. Mad? I don't think so!

05:27  
Blogger Zhoen said...

Gina,
I'm just reacting here to how someone else was mindlessly attacked in a forum for making an anti-disney comment. Mostly, the company is an irrelevancy.

I'm glad you got to see Yellowstone, one of the few places so immense it really can't be overrated.

Lucy,
Agreed. I read them when I was still going to church, and found them wonderful. Very glad I read them while I still could, and can keep the fond memories.

11:42  
Blogger The Crow said...

The last Disney movie I enjoyed was Sleeping Beauty and that was because of the art work - and the three fairy godmothers.

I also liked Gus-Gus the cat in Cinderella.

After that, the politics got in the way.

14:09  
Blogger English Rider said...

If we could believe that children are encouraged to read the books as well and form their own opinions it would not be as bad. It really underlines the lack of critical thinking which is scary as hell.

15:51  
Blogger The Crow said...

...uh...that's Gus-Gus, the mouse...

19:31  
Blogger Zhoen said...

Crow,
Yeah, cuz in Disney, the mice that pee all over and carry disease and eat grain are the good guys, and the cats that are kept as pets and kill vermin are bad guys. Always.

21:56  
Blogger The Crow said...

Re: Gus-Gus - Well, that wasn't exactly what I had in mind, but I certainly see your point.

I guess I've known and loved too many cats for me to see Disney's portrayal of them as real.

:)

04:45  
Blogger Zhoen said...

Crow,
Oh, Gus-gus was lovable, appealing to every sense. Perfectly created to do exactly that. Individually blameless.

Only in context, within the overall pattern, does the bias of the industry that created him start looking evil.

09:18  
Blogger Geosomin said...

I've always been annoyed by the whole princess thing in Disney cartoons...I have fond childhood memories of goofy and chip and dale, but for the most part...well...they keep taking classic tales and girlying them up. How about a self rescuing princess?

I got nervous when they aquired Pixar...

10:55  

Post a Comment

<< Home